Former Chief of the General Staff Pavel Muraveika did not even last two months as deputy head of Lukashenka’s Administration. The unexpected transfer of the official to the post of chairman of the Vitsyebsk Regional Executive Committee looks more like exile than a promotion. What might Muraveika have done to fall out of favour?
Back in September, there were no signs of trouble. On 28 September, Aliaksandr Lukashenka appointed Muraveika, then chief of the General Staff, as deputy head of his Administration. The newly appointed official said he had been tasked with carrying out “in-depth work”, ensuring the security of the “rapidly developing economic sector” and the “expanding social sphere”. However, Head of the Administration Dzmitry Krutoi described Muraveika’s responsibilities somewhat differently. According to him, the new deputy was to oversee several strategic projects, coordinate the network of Lukashenka’s regional aides and handle citizens’ appeals.
Such contradictory and convoluted descriptions raised certain suspicions: either Muraveika had been appointed without anyone having properly worked out his responsibilities, or those in charge preferred not to disclose the actual tasks assigned to him. We suggested that the move might be part of an effort to strengthen the position of Security Council State Secretary Aliaksandr Valfovich within this government body, ahead of impending purges in the security agencies. The Security Council and the Administration would need to coordinate those efforts. Moreover, when appointing Muraveika, Lukashenka spoke of strengthening the “security sector and its area of responsibility”.
All this seemed plausible until today, when Lukashenka unexpectedly sent Muraveika to the Vitsyebsk Region, appointing him chairman of the regional executive committee. Although this is not formally a demotion — both positions belong to the highest, second-rank category of state civil service — the move looks much more like exile than a promotion.
Of course, more mundane explanations should not be ruled out. For instance, the personnel shortage facing the Belarusian regime may have become so acute that there is simply no one left to appoint as chairman of a regional executive committee. The authorities are therefore forced to reshuffle the same deck, sending whoever is available to tackle problem areas. Muraveika’s military background, combined with Lukashenka’s faith in the power of military discipline to restore order locally, may support this explanation.
Still, this personnel decision looks somewhat illogical. Why bring Muraveika into the Administration only to send him out of sight a month and a half later? Or did the newly appointed official fall out of favour over some alleged misconduct?
So, let us offer our own explanation for the official’s apparent exile. It may be conspiratorial, but it is quite an elegant theory.
Remember how, in early October this year, Latvia’s border guard reported a group of armed, masked men who had staged a provocation on the Belarusian-Latvian border? They were said to have escorted a group of migrants, “actively pushing” them towards Latvia. Several hours after Latvian border guards thwarted an attempt to cross the border illegally, the same masked men entered Latvian territory, damaged equipment, stole surveillance cameras and fled back into Belarus.
Responsibility for the provocation was claimed by a group calling itself the “Black Russes”, which also announced its intention to continue carrying out sabotage operations against EU countries bordering Belarus.
It is difficult to believe that such informal armed groups could operate independently in present-day Belarus. Clearly, a provocation of this kind could not have taken place without the knowledge and involvement of the security services, including Russian agencies, since the Kremlin has the greatest interest in escalating tensions.
And now for the question.
Could Moscow have carried out such a special operation, even on the territory of an ally, without its knowledge? Most likely not. At the very least, this would have been necessary to avoid potential misunderstandings: what if Belarusian border guards, unaware of the plan, opened fire on armed intruders? The provocation therefore had to be coordinated. It also had to be prepared in advance: these “Russes” fighters had to be invented, a website and social media accounts created, videos recorded, and so on. The fingerprints of some GRU (Main Intelligence Directorate of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces) unit are obvious from a mile away. Most likely, it was working in partnership with Belarusian military intelligence, which is subordinate to the chief of the General Staff. Until the end of September this year, that position was held by General Muraveika.
The details are not essential: whether the Belarusians carried out the operation “in the name of and on behalf of” someone else, or simply assisted the Russians. What matters is that they knew about it. But did Lukashenka know? Or has cooperation between the Belarusian and Russian militaries become so extensive that there is no longer any need to clear every “minor detail”, every request from Moscow, with the politician? Perhaps he would have objected: under the current circumstances, he has little reason to further damage relations with neighbouring countries, which are already far from straightforward.
Let us recall what the Belarusian politician said shortly after the high-profile provocation on the border with Latvia.
Lukashenka claimed that the incident had been staged by the Latvian security services themselves: “We have nothing to do with this, with people in masks, military personnel, entering their territory, seizing or capturing someone, or pushing some group of migrants in there.”
According to him, “an operation of this kind, involving entry into the territory of a neighbouring state, is impossible without the president’s approval. Such things were not coordinated with me. And therefore, they did not take place.”
But what if we assume that Lukashenka was not lying in this instance? What if he really did not know? Or perhaps he was given somewhat different information about the details of the provocation, while its foreign policy consequences ultimately proved far greater than anticipated.
The authorities began looking into the incident. Otherwise, why would Belarus’s Ministry of Information have designated the social media accounts and website of the “Black Russes” group as “extremist materials”?
And as they followed the trail, they may have identified the person on the Belarusian side who had organised the provocation. Or helped organise it. Or approved it. That person turned out to be Muraveika, who headed the General Staff until the end of September. Yes, the border incident took place when the general was already working in the Administration. But preparations for it had begun well in advance.
Muraveika is certainly capable of something like this. He has always presented himself as a “hawk”. At one point, he threatened to carve out the Suwałki Corridor; at another, he waved the threat of the Oreshnik missile. And he clearly has no shortage of connections with Russians after studying at the Military Academy of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces.
That may be what he paid the price for. The head of the Administration, Krutoi, who is responsible for personnel policy, may also have used Muraveika’s failure to his own advantage. He hardly needs a “watchdog” appointed by Valfovich breathing down his neck. And now a convenient opportunity has presented itself. Who knows — perhaps Krutoi himself suggested to Lukashenka that the disgraced Muraveika be sent to the Vitsyebsk Region. To that very border with Latvia where the “Black Russes” group caused trouble. To one of the most problematic regions. Only now, instead of commanding special forces or carrying out “in-depth work”, he will be expected to restore order in cowsheds.
“Of course, agriculture will be the main focus of your work. Especially since we need to clearly determine how we are going to move forward there,” Lukashenka told the newly appointed regional executive committee chairman Muraveika.
You have to admit, it is an elegant arrangement. It is unlikely that the former chief of the General Staff ever dreamed of such a turn in his career. And although this theory reeks of elaborate conspiracy from a mile away, who knows? The reality we live in sometimes throws up plot twists so extraordinary that they leave us stunned.
***
The opinions and assessments expressed by the author may not reflect those of the Reform.news editorial team.