“So How Many Jews Live There?” Lukashenka Meets Head of Russia’s Jewish Autonomous Region

Aliaksandr Lukashenka met today with Maria Kostyuk, governor of Russia’s Jewish Autonomous Region. He asked her how many Jews live in the region and why Belarusians had been taken there but never returned. Kostyuk replied that Belarusians had gone to the region to make things better.

Welcoming his guest, Lukashenka noted that Belarusians had played a “significant part” in the creation of the Jewish Autonomous Region.

“I would say not just a significant part. The region itself was established in 1934, but the resettlement began much earlier,” Kostyuk replied.

“Around 1928…” Lukashenka said.

“When the first trains arrived, the first and second trains came from here. And now we have started looking at the ethnic composition, examining it and going through the archives. There was a lot of activity during the Soviet era,” Kostyuk said.

“But why did you resettle our people there in the 1920s?” Lukashenka asked.

“No, that is not how it happened. They were not resettled. The situation was different. The country was vast. Every part of a vast country had to be made prosperous. So those who knew how to make things better went there. They went to make things better,” the Russian official said.

Dmitry Krutoi, head of Lukashenka’s Administration, laughed at her remarks. Lukashenka also reacted with a smile.

“What an ideology! I had no idea. I had always viewed this with some suspicion. Why did they have to resettle people?” Lukashenka said.

It should be noted that the late 1920s and early 1930s were a period of mass collectivisation, dekulakisation and large-scale repression.

“It is like Marquez’s ‘One Hundred Years of Solitude’. Every nation has its own hundred years of solitude, its own path and level of development. Those who arrived made things better. Then others came. Some returned, while those who stayed had to develop the region. And that is how it all went on,” Kostyuk said.

“Well, you did not exactly send many of our people back to us from there,” Lukashenka told her.

“But where would we have come from otherwise?” his counterpart replied.

She presented him with an archival document on resettlement from Belarus between 1928 and 1938.

During the meeting, Lukashenka also could not resist asking the head of the Jewish Autonomous Region a pointed question.

“They call it the Jewish Autonomous Region. Right? So how many Jews are there? In percentage terms? Not everyone there is Jewish, of course; everything has become mixed, as they say. So how many Jews are there?” he asked.

“This is not a conversation about Jews; it is about territory. A vast country. Within that vast country, a special territory was established where the titular nation of what is now the Jewish Autonomous Region could move freely. People came from all over, from every corner. The main idea was international in scope: people were to move here from beyond the country’s borders. It was the only territory of its kind, an international one, with a great many mixed marriages. There was a broad multicultural dialogue. Of course, the titular nation maintained its foundations. But at the same time, this was the only place where Jews were not called names for being Jews, and where they genuinely felt at home. There are entire films from that time, beautiful ones, showing how they travelled there in search of happiness. And that was happiness. So much time has passed, but the Jewish Autonomous Region, as the first Jewish entity, has remained the first. And it has remained a place associated with happiness, peace and all the values for which it was originally established. Nothing has changed. That is why today we tell everyone who feels uncomfortable somewhere: you can return, you can come here,” Kostyuk began her answer.

“So you are saying Jews can come…” Lukashenka interjected.

“Everyone. Well, you may not be Jewish, but you are obliged to live like a Jew. We had three waves of resettlement, and people from Kazakhstan and many other places came, including my grandmother. Jewish identity is one thing, but the nation and the territory itself are another. My grandmother’s entire life unfolded there. She had seven children, and then grandchildren and great-grandchildren,” the guest continued.

“So, are you saying that this area, where you are the governor, was created as a kind of… a special district, a region where Jews from abroad could come, or was it specifically established for them?” Lukashenka asked.

“I think this region was created to show how a multicultural dialogue can work, how everyone can live together in one territory if there is a desire for friendship and mutual trust. But nothing has changed today. Look, we are still all about peace. We were the first, and many other territories for Jews were established afterwards, but we have always stood for peace and continue to do so. Families are friends with one another, people form relationships here, communicate and develop,” Kostyuk replied.

“All right. But did Jews go there?” Lukashenka asked again.

“Jews did go there,” the Russian official replied.

“So how many Jews are there now?” Lukashenka pressed.

“One per cent now,” Dmitry Krutoi attempted to interject.

“As I have been saying, everyone there is… you cannot live any other way. The spirit is like that, you know,” Kostyuk said.

“Well, I see. Not everyone, but everyone,” Lukashenka concluded.

Later, Lukashenka, as usual, said that our people live everywhere. He once again reflected on people’s roots.

“The main thing is that our people live there and here, and we can cooperate with them and so on. It is difficult to work out who we are there, especially in Belarus. There is such a mixture here: Jews and Poles, Ukrainians and Russians — it has all become mixed together. And what emerged was a Belarusian, as I say: a Belarusian is a Russian with a quality mark. I don’t know what Boris Vyacheslavovich…” he said, addressing Russia’s ambassador to Belarus, Boris Gryzlov.

“I agree,” the ambassador replied.